Mortgage Rates Predictions
Predicting mortgage rates is about as reliable as an online psychic, especially in today’s market. There are far too many factors which affect mortgage rates for even Ben Bernanke to predict what rates will do from one day to the next. The trick the Fed is facing now is lowering the Fed rates enough to boost the economy (Fed rate cuts do not always equal a cut in mortgage rates; see my blog from Feb 25th for info on this) but not so much that we weaken the dollar and head straight into a recession.
From Bloomberg.com: Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke’s readiness to cut interest rates to avert a recession is stoking concerns that prices will get out of hand.
“If you move aggressively to cut interest rates and stimulate the economy, then you risk fueling inflation,” Democratic Representative Greg Meeks of New York said at yesterday’s Senate Banking Committee hearing.
Senator Richard Shelby of Alabama, the Senate panel’s ranking Republican, said he wants to “make sure” the Fed “focuses on the risks associated with increasing inflation,” citing higher gold, oil and consumer prices.
The FOMC last month lowered the benchmark rate by 1.25 percentage points in nine days, the steepest reduction in two decades, to 3 percent. The two decisions each saw one dissenting vote on the Fed panel.
“They will keep cutting,” said Kurt Karl, chief U.S. economist at Swiss Reinsurance Co. in New York. “If inflation looks like it is taking off quite rapidly, or inflation expectations take off, they will have to backtrack.”
Representative Gary Miller, a California Republican, told Bernanke that with continued high oil prices, “it may be more difficult for the Fed to cut interest rates,” and he asked the Fed chief about his other options besides lowering rates.
“We do face a difficult situation,” Bernanke acknowledged. Oil and food prices have been climbing “rapidly,” and there are “slightly greater upside risks to the projections” for inflation now than a month ago.
It is a very tricky situation we presently face; below is the latest economic data which factors into what mortgage rates might do…
Driving Interest Rates — January 2008: Weak Economic Data / Falling Stock Prices / Emergency Fed Rate Cut / Regular Fed Rate Cut
Treasuries soared in January, sending yields sharply lower as weak economic data and turmoil in the financial markets spurred the Federal Reserve into making deep interest rate cuts. The benchmark, 10-Year Note saw a decline in its yield of 44 basis points. Since the end of last June, the yield had declined by 115 basis points.
The year started out with bearish news from the manufacturing sector. The Institute for Supply Management (ISM) said that its manufacturing index came in at 47.7 for December following a reading of 50.8 in November. Any reading below 50.0 indicates a general contraction of activity relative to the preceding month and December’s contraction was the first in eleven months and the weakest reading in over four-and-a-half years.
Another major sign of economic sluggishness came a few days later when the Labor Department said that nonfarm payrolls rose by just 18,000 in December. While this was the fifty-second straight month of job growth, it was the weakest of them. Besides the weak job growth, observers were startled by a jump in the unemployment rate, the percent of the active workforce without jobs. It rose from 4.7% to a two-year high of 5.0%. The jump was the largest since October of 2001.
Adding to the attraction of Treasuries was the sharp downturn in stocks. In the first five sessions of the month, the Dow lost 676 points. But stocks exhibited a technical bounce in the following two sessions, allowing bond traders to consolidate some of their profits after eight days of advances.
New supply also pressured bonds as the Treasury auctioned $8 billion in 10-Year TIPS (Treasury Inflation Protected Securities) on the 10th. TIPS differ from conventional Treasury securities in that although they have a fixed coupon (interest) rate, but their face value is regularly adjusted according to the Consumer Price Index, so the interest payout amounts fluctuate according to the changes in inflation. At maturity, the greater of the inflation-adjusted principal or the original face value is paid out.
While the auction was met with tepid demand, the bond market recovered since Federal Reserve Board Chairman Ben Bernanke had given a speech on the 10th where he noted that “in light of recent changes in the outlook for and the risks to growth, additional policy easing may well be necessary.”
Because of deteriorating economic conditions and problems in the credit market due to pricing difficulties associated with certain mortgage-backed securities, the Fed had already taken a number of dramatic actions. In August, the monetary policy committee (FOMC; the Federal Open Market Committee), in an unscheduled meeting, cut the discount rate by 0.50% to 5.75%. The discount rate is the rate charged to banks for loans directly from the Fed. In addition, it extended the payback period. In September, at the regular policy meeting, the committee cut its target for the fed funds rate (interest rate for short-term loans between banks) by 0.50% to 4.75% from 5.25%. This was the first rate cut since June of 2003. The discount rate was also cut again by 0.50% to 5.25%.
In October, the rates were cut again but by only 0.25%, bringing the fed funds rate down to 4.50% and the discount rate to 5.00%. The rates were cut again in December by 0.25% to 4.25% and 4.75%. In addition, the Fed began offering banks another direct source of funds since borrowing through the discount window had traditionally been perceived as a sign that a bank is in trouble. In December, the Fed instituted what it calls a Term Auction Facility (TAF), a temporary program whereby short-term funds can be obtained on an auction basis using a broad range of collateral including mortgage-related securities.
More weak economic news came out on the 15th. Retail sales fell in December and the weakness was broad-based. The large but volatile category of autos and light trucks declined; but even excluding the category, sales were down. And they were even lower if the volatile category of gas station sales was also excluded. The growing string of bearish economic data put further pressure on the Fed to keep cutting rates. Treasuries benefit from the prospect of lower rates since it means lower coupon rates on upcoming issues that will compete with those already in the market.
Lower rates also eventually benefit stocks by making it easier for businesses and consumers to borrow and spend money, but the grim outlook for near-term corporate earnings continued to weigh on the equities market.
Speculation that the Fed would be cutting again was strengthened on the 17th when Mr. Bernanke, speaking before the House Budget Committee said, “On the whole, despite improvements in some areas, the financial situation remains fragile, and many funding markets remain impaired. Adverse economic or financial news thus has the potential to increase financial strains and to lead to further constraints on the supply of credit to households and businesses.” He further noted that the Fed must be “prepared to act in a decisive and timely manner and, in particular, to counter any adverse dynamics that might threaten economic or financial stability.”
Action came sooner than expected. In an emergency meeting on the 22nd, the FOMC decided to cut its target for the fed funds rate by 0.75% from 4.25% to 3.50%. The discount rate was also slashed by 0.75% from 4.75% to 4.00%. The cuts were made following steep losses in global stock markets on Monday when the U.S. market was closed for Martin Luther King Day and in Tuesday trade (overnight before the U.S. markets opened).
The Fed move prevented a severe melt-down in stocks but the indices still lost ground on the 22nd. The Dow had dropped again in five straight sessions, losing 807 points. Stock rebounded in the next couple of sessions, once again allowing bond traders to take back some of their profits. Supply was again a factor as the Treasury auctioned $8 billion in 20-Year TIPS on the 24th. But a drop in stocks the next day helped Treasuries recover the next day.
In the beginning of the last week of the month, bonds were held back again by supply pressure from the monthly 2- and 5-Year Note offerings. Some uncertainty over what the Fed would do at the month’s regular meeting on the 29th and 30th also kept traders in a defensive posture. The month ended with more gains for Treasuries as the Fed once again cut the fed funds and discount rates by 0.50%. This brought the fed funds rate down to 3.00% and the discount rate to 3.50%.
Stocks closed out the month with a winning session but for the whole month, the Dow lost 614.56 points or 4.63%. The Nasdaq lost 262.42 points or 9.89%.
